✊ Hook Stacking: A lesson from Taylor Swift on creating an ultra-catchy show


​

1,163 WORDS | READ TIME: 4.4 MIN

Hi friends,

Good songs are built around a clear, memorable hook.

Great songs are built around several.

And then there are songs by Taylor Swift.

The master of hook writing who brings the craft to another level.

Take We Are Never Getting Back Together.

In the first 62 seconds, Taylor drops distinct 6 hooks.

By my count, the song as a whole has 12, many of them repeating throughout.

For Taylor, this was just a warm-up, however.

In Shake It Off, she crams 10 distinct hooks into the first 60 seconds, with a grand total of 17 by song’s end.

This pattern repeats throughout all of her hits.

In each, she layers hook upon hook upon hook upon hook of every variety—melodic, lyrical, vocal, emotional, harmonic, percussive, instrumental, production-oriented, and more.

This progressive stacking of hooks results in songs with multiple opportunities to worm their way into our ears, brains, and—often—souls.

If the first hook didn’t grab you, the next one—or the one after that—will.

But for Taylor, hook crafting isn't limited to her songwriting.

As her aura has grown, each album, each distinct, defined era of her story has become a hook of its own.

And then there are the subtle winks, easter eggs, and clues for her fans to decipher—meta hooks that Taylor weaves throughout her songs, liner notes, artwork, marketing, and performance.

If you’re looking for an explanation to her success, a good place to start might be that she’s simply given us more hooks to latch onto than anyone else.

And if you want to maximize your own potential for growth, this practice of Hook Stacking is a good place to start.

🔥 Why Most Interview Podcasts Fail

Almost every interview-based podcast host imagines that if they could just get bigger, better, more well-known guests, their show would take off.

But while celebrity guests certainly do lend credibility to a show, they rarely lead to growth.

In fact, they may even hold it back… at least if you approach your show the way most interview hosts do.

In this roast, we dissect a show that interviews well-known musical legends… but falls into a familiar interview-show trap that makes it hard to grow.

​

Like good songs, good podcasts are built around a clear central hook.

Great shows, however—shows that vacuum up attention—are designed & constructed atop a stack of them.

On its own, any one of these hooks might be enough to attract listeners to the shows.

The combination, however, makes the show utterly irresistible.

When it comes to podcasting, hooks can be broken into two categories:

  1. Show Level Hooks
  2. Episode Level Hooks

Within each category, there are a series of opportunities to create hooks.

The more hooks you weave into your show, the more listeners you'll attract and retain.

Show Level Hooks

Show Topic – The topic of any show is one of the foundational hooks, with its sharpness increasing the narrower, more unique, and more distinctive it is. Within the topic, there are multiple potential sub-hooks.

  1. Audience – The specific group of people the show is addressing the topic to. Again, the more specific and unique the audience, the sharper the hook.
    ​
  2. Goal/Purpose – The specific promised outcome the show makes to listeners. This could be an outcome that is delivered consistently in every episode or a larger destination the show promises to take listeners to over time. Again, the more unique and specific this outcome is compared to other shows, the sharper the hook.
    ​
  3. Method – A unique method or framework the show uses to deliver the goal or promise of the show is an additional hook that can be stacked on top of the topic.

Concept – Stacked on top of the topic is the way you explore it through your podcast, which provides another hook opportunity. The concept hook can be broken down further into two additional potential hooks:

  1. Angle – A unique and distinctive lens you approach your primary topic through—like a show that explores the topic of podcast marketing through the lens of data for example…
    ​
  2. Format – A show format that is distinct and refreshing compared to other shows on your topic.

Host – The host of a show can be a compelling hook if they:

  1. Are already well-known (read: famous) to the extent that people would seek out their specific take on a topic.
    ​
  2. Are not well-known, but have significant, highly-credible subject matter expertise that makes them a compelling person to hear from on the topic. The more experience or credibility the host has in their field, the sharper this hook becomes.
    ​
  3. Have an unconventional background that intersects with the topic in a compelling way that makes them a fascinating, perhaps unorthodox or counter-narrative voice on the subject.

Cover Art – Artwork can be a powerful visual hook in its own right when done right.

Some of the elements of hooky artwork include professional, interesting, refreshing, unique design, being evocative of the topic, vibe, and tone of the show, being clear, and hinting at (or calling out directly) the show’s inherent tension.

Title – Truly great titles are hard to come by, but they can provide a powerful hook for a show.

The best titles are often built around a play or twist on a known phrase that is both evocative and refreshing. These titles are linguistically pleasing, tend to roll off the tongue and tell us enough about the show to pique our curiosity and lean in to look closer.

The crux of this type of titling is it can’t come off as forced, ham-handed, or trying to be clever… which it often does by all but the savviest of creators.

Description – Especially the first line—which is often all a new listener sees in a podcast app—should build on the title and cover art to provide enough new information about the show to further pull in the listener.

If the title and cover art are evocative, the first line should concretely lay out the value proposition of the show. If the title and cover art are clear, the first line of the description should evoke something bigger and deeper.

Tone/Style – In a space with shows that all feel and sound the same, a show can create a powerful hook by adopting a distinct, clearly defined tone and style. Take the aggressive, blunt, sweary, Everyone Hates Marketers, for example (a show which also has strong cover art and title hooks).

Crafting Your Hooks

Outside of the host hook, any and all of these show-level hooks can be applied to any show.

And they should be.

Do a search on a random topic in your favourite podcast app and you’ll find that most shows lack even a single strong, compelling hook.

Which is great news for you.

Because while your show likely isn’t currently making use of all of the potential show-level hooks discussed here, if you’re willing to take the practice of hook crafting seriously, you have an incredible opportunity to stand out.

And grow significantly.

In a medium like podcasting where listeners typically discover—and recommend—shows as a whole, over individual episodes, the more hooks you can stack inside your show, the better your results will be.

What’s more, an abundance of show-level hooks raises the floor of each individual episode within the show.

Said differently, with an ultra-hooky show, each episode needs to do less work to hook and retain listeners on its own.

Speaking of episodes, we’ll be breaking down episode-level hooks tomorrow.

In the meantime, hit reply and let me know one of the following:

  1. How many of the 11(ish) hooks discussed here would you say your show has
  2. What’s your favourite show and how many show-level hooks does it employ? As I’m building this idea out I’d love some examples to reference.

Oh, and I'll be updating the full post here if you want to refer back to it in the future to compare your show against.

Til tomorrow.

Stay Scrappy,

In 2025, I'm doing something a little different when it comes to my 1:1 Podcast Growth Engine Program.

In the program, I spend 10-15 hours auditing your show, record a feature film-length video report breaking down what's working, what's not, and what you need to do, and then work with you directly on an ongoing basis to grow your podcast, email list, and revenue.

After working myself to near-burnout in 2024 averaging more than an audit per week, in 2025, I'll be implementing a hard cap of 26 new Podcast Growth Engine clients for the year.

In addition to the cap, as of January 1, 2025, the price to get started is going up from $3,000 for the initial 3-month sprint to $4,500.

If you're interested in reserving your spot in my audit queue, I've set aside 10 slots at the current pricing.

Plus, if you sign up before the new year, you'll get immediate access to all the playbooks, twice weekly live calls with me, the PMA community, and much more while waiting for your audit and 3-month sprint to officially start—all at no extra cost.

Last year I ran a similar deal and many clients ended up getting as much as 6-months free bonus time.

If you're interested in learning more and grabbing one of the 2025 spots, reply with "Growth Engine" and I'll send you over all the details.

Are algorithms killing creativity?

​

Thanks for being a PMA Member!

Jump into the community and let us know what you need help with... or if this issue sparked a question you'd love to discuss further!

Reply anytime, I love hearing from you!

​

​

​