✊ Why most interview podcasts fail


460 WORDS | READ TIME: 1.7 MIN

Happy Friday friends,

Of all the many formats you can design a podcast around, none is more popular than the interview.

It’s no wonder why.

Interview shows (can) require less prep than scripted solo shows and certainly less time & money than narrative shows. And unlike co-hosted shows, if you have an on-air falling out with a guest, you never have to talk to them again!

Interviews also allow you as a host to explore diverse ideas and perspectives beyond your own circle of expertise, expand your network, lend themselves to collaborations and guest swaps, and more.

Yep, there’s a lot to love about the interview format.

Except, well one thing…

They’re the single hardest format to grow.

Which is ironic, seeing as many hosts start interview shows thinking they’ll be easier to grow due to the exposure to their guests’ audiences.

In particular, hosts often imagine “big” well-known (even bone fide celebrity) guests to be their show’s knights in shining armour, coveting and chasing them down them down with ruthless obsession.

Unfortunately, that exposure rarely materializes.

Either because the guests don’t share their episodes, or they do but their audiences aren’t aligned with your content.

Add in the fact that interview shows are a dime a dozen on any conceivable topic, often with little to immediately differentiate one over another, and it becomes painfully, obvioously clear…

There’s a lot to hate about the interview format.

So if you produce an interview show, what are you supposed to do?

Do you switch up your format?

Double down, become the best interviewer you can be, and settle in for the long, slow grind of growth.

Or is there another way to think about interview shows?

One that immediately sets your show apart from the dozens of other interview shows in your niche and positions yours as the must-listen interviews on your topic?

These are the questions we’re exploring in this week’s podcast roast.

On the skewer this week is A Breath of Fresh Air a music podcast featuring interviews with world-famous classic rock musicians from the 60’s, 70’s, and 80’s.

Guests include members of Deep Purple, Fleetwood Mac, Steely Dan, Cheap Trick, Kool & the Gang, The Jackson 5, and many many more legendary guests.

But are guests like these enough to grow this show?

And if not, what would?

Check out the roast to hear our breakdown.

If you're feeling brave enough to submit your own show for a roast, here's how to do it:

  1. Subscribe to our show, Podcast Marketing Trends Explained
  2. Leave us a review that includes your show name
  3. Wait nervously on pins and needles, hoping that we don't (or do) pick you

Have a great weekend. And as always...

Stay Scrappy,

In 2025, I'm doing something a little different when it comes to my 1:1 Podcast Growth Engine Program.

In the program, I spend 10-15 hours auditing your show, record a feature film-length video report breaking down what's working, what's not, and what you need to do, and then work with you directly on an ongoing basis to grow your podcast, email list, and revenue.

After working myself to near-burnout in 2024 averaging more than an audit per week, in 2025, I'll be implementing a hard cap of 26 new Podcast Growth Engine clients for the year.

In addition to the cap, as of January 1, 2025, the price to get started is going up from $3,000 for the initial 3-month sprint to $4,500.

If you're interested in reserving your spot in my audit queue, I've set aside 10 slots at the current pricing.

Plus, if you sign up before the new year, you'll get immediate access to all the playbooks, twice weekly live calls with me, the PMA community, and much more while waiting for your audit and 3-month sprint to officially start—all at no extra cost.

Last year I ran a similar deal and many clients ended up getting as much as 6-months free bonus time.

If you're interested in learning more and grabbing one of the 2025 spots, reply with "Growth Engine" and I'll send you over all the details.

Are algorithms killing creativity?

Thanks for being a PMA Member!

Jump into the community and let us know what you need help with... or if this issue sparked a question you'd love to discuss further!

Reply anytime, I love hearing from you!